The World's Toughest Book Critics ℠
 
Cover art for MELVIN SAYS THERE'S MONSTERS

MELVIN SAYS THERE'S MONSTERS

Age Range: 5 - 8
Diminutive Melvin, "this weird kid at my school with crooked eyes and bushy hair," loves to scare his would-be friends out of their candy with tales of the monsters who wait in their closets at night. Read full review
Buy this book from
Buy this app from Apple
From Apple
Similar books suggested by our critics:
Cover art for MUTANT ABCS
by Dwayne Ferguson
 
MELVIN SAYS THERE'S MONSTERS
Diminutive Melvin, “this weird kid at my school with crooked eyes and bushy hair,” loves to scare his would-be friends out of their candy with tales of the monsters who wait in their closets at night. The kids laugh, but, in bed, those who laughed at Melvin cower; the next day they’re handing over their snacks for monster advice. Snarky and sophisticated, the app features understated yet cinematic animation bringing to life Aly’s lively illustrations. The app is a study in restraint; its menu, ever-present in the top-left corner of a border that surrounds the story, has only three options. The “Read to me” voiceover is well-acted, but could be confusing for beginning readers—in several instances, the narration doesn’t match the accompanying text word-for-word. The app’s biggest problem is the titular character, a creepy, two-faced liar who isn’t redeemed. He’s apparently allowed by the narrator, a schoolmate, to keep on taking advantage of other kids for their treats. At least the app design, unlike Melvin, shows restraint; it’s not overloaded with sugar-high excess. (iPad storybook app. 5-8)

Review Posted Online: Dec. 22nd, 2010
screenshot
screenshot
screenshot
screenshot
screenshot