Cover art for BALLYWHINNEY GIRL

BALLYWHINNEY GIRL

Age Range: 6 - 10
Buy now from
AMAZON.COM
BARNES & NOBLE
LOCAL BOOKSELLER
Add to my list

KIRKUS REVIEW

Maeve and her grandpa find an Irish bog mummy when they are out cutting peat.

Young Maeve narrates the story in free verse that incorporates dialogue. The dialect is lyrical and captures the astonishment of the girl and her grandfather, who first believe they have found a murdered child, followed by awe when they are told it is a mummy: “I gasped. / A girl! / A girl like me, a thousand years ago / dead and dropped into this quiet place. / Who was she? / What had happened?” Despite a promise from the archaeologists to share all they learn, Maeve is uneasy when they take the mummy from the site. A police sergeant later visits, providing an update with scanty details about the mummy, belying the abilities of modern archaeological techniques and possibly disappointing youngsters excited to learn about the past. Enough information is presented so that Maeve identifies even more closely with the long-ago girl, increasing her ambivalence about the discovery. Indeed Bunting, in an afterword, recounts the history of finds, stating that while some were handled with respect, others were treated as curiosities. McCully uses watercolor with pen and ink to create a moody landscape that reflects Maeve’s musings, including her final, fanciful vision of the girl walking on the bog.

To balance this perspective, pair this with Mummies, Bones, and Body Parts, by Charlotte Wilcox (2000). (Picture book. 6-10)

Pub Date: March 6th, 2012
ISBN: 978-0-547-55843-1
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Clarion
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 15th, 2012



MORE BY EVE BUNTING

Children Cover art for HAVE YOU SEEN MY NEW BLUE SOCKS?
by Eve Bunting
Children Cover art for THE VOYAGE OF THE <i>SEA WOLF</i>
by Eve Bunting
Children Cover art for  BEST SUMMER EVER
by Eve Bunting
Children Cover art for FROG AND FRIENDS
by Eve Bunting
Children Cover art for PIRATE BOY
by Eve Bunting
Children Cover art for THE PIRATE CAPTAIN'S DAUGHTER
by Eve Bunting

MORE BY EMILY ARNOLD MCCULLY

Children Cover art for SAM AND THE BIG KIDS
by Emily Arnold McCully
Children Cover art for SAM AND THE BIG KIDS
by Emily Arnold McCully
Children Cover art for THE HELPFUL PUPPY
by Kim Zarins
Children Cover art for BALLERINA SWAN
by Allegra Kent
Children Cover art for LATE NATE IN A RACE
by Emily Arnold McCully
Children Cover art for LATE NATE IN A RACE
by Emily Arnold McCully


SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

Children Cover art for DISCOVERING THE INCA ICE MAIDEN
by Johan Reinhard
Children Cover art for MUMMIES, PYRAMIDS, AND PHARAOHS
by Gail Gibbons
Children Cover art for MUMMIES, BONES, AND BODY PARTS
by Charlotte Wilcox