The determined pigeon of the Caldecott Honor–winning Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! (2003) returns in a more subdued performance that will nevertheless appeal to fans of the first. The pigeon is about to eat the hot dog he’s found, when a sly, persevering, small yellow duckling “scooty scoot scoots” up with a series of questions and comments. Willems again expertly captures the personality and emotions of the droll pigeon (“not a hot dog; my hot dog”) and the “guest star” duckling, who manages to trick the pigeon into giving him what he wants, taking notes about the taste of a hot dog. “Each morsel is a joy! A celebration in a bun!” says Pigeon. “Does it taste like chicken?” asks the winsome duck. Another tantrum ensues, but the hot dog is split and shared. Duckling tops off his triumph with a complaint that gives him the final word, “Hmm . . . needs mustard.” Some readers may feel this tale could also use a bit more mustard, but children who already love the pigeon will be satisfied. (Picture book. 2-8)
