Kirkus Reviews QR Code
I AM A THIEF! by Abigail Rayner Kirkus Star

I AM A THIEF!

by Abigail Rayner ; illustrated by Molly Ruttan

Pub Date: Sept. 3rd, 2019
ISBN: 978-0-7358-4289-2
Publisher: NorthSouth

Eliza is appalled to discover that she is a thief; can she ever redeem herself?

It all starts when Eliza—Line Leader, Caring Friend, Captain of the Worm Rescue Team—swipes a sparkly stone from the table in her classroom. It wasn’t her fault. The stone made her do it. But as soon as it’s hers, Eliza becomes a thief. Her reflection looks back at her through a bandit’s mask, and the stone, wearing devilish horns and a pointy tail, oppresses her all day. As the entire class searches for the stone, Eliza agonizes about putting it back. What if someone sees? She goes home and asks the adults in her life if they have ever stolen anything. Her father hasn’t, but nearly everyone else admits to having stolen something. Still, Eliza goes to bed in tears, thinking of her disappointed classmates. The next day, she returns the stone to Ms. Delano. And rather than judge her harshly, Ms. Delano calls her…“BRAVE?” Eliza realizes that “nobody is just a thief. Everyone is a lot of things!” This humorous story speaks to anyone who has made a regrettable mistake, rounding it out with a gently ironic surprise final spread. The playful illustrations feature textured shading and expressive lines highlighting Eliza’s active imagination. Eliza and her family present as white; Ms. Delano has brown skin, and Eliza’s classmates are multiracial.

Hilarious and sweet, with a gentle, affirming moral.

(Picture book. 4-9)