A NEW FRIEND FOR MARMALADE by Alison Reynolds

A NEW FRIEND FOR MARMALADE

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 5

KIRKUS REVIEW

A little boy who disrupts the play of two girls and their pet cat finds redemption but no real consequences.

The opening verso sports a wavy line of stylized lettering: “Ella, Maddy, and Marmalade were best friends.” On the recto, the cartoonlike girls and orange cat, all with eyes closed in contentment, trot across a bare white background, nicely inviting readers to turn the page. At the turn, the girls are building a playhouse as “Toby, the boy from across the road, joined in.” Children will enjoy this understatement as they view the resultant havoc. Although Toby shows no malice, he also shows little remorse as he thrice destroys the collaborative sandbox creations of Maddy and Ella. With maddeningly stereotypical gender norms, the girls show both restraint and passive-aggressiveness in reaction to Toby’s behavior. All three children are wide-eyed, pen-and-ink moppets, with the girls in dresses and Toby wearing a superhero’s cape. Marmalade is a cutesy, large-headed cat who infuriates the girls by taking a fancy to Toby. When Toby frightens Marmalade up a tree, his cape then provides a means of rescue, and the next day, all three children and the cat play together happily. The artwork and layout are reminiscent of a mid-1970s aesthetic, an odd environment for a theme that seems to value individualistic, destructive behavior over collaborative, creative play.

This will resonate with parents who are in denial about their progeny’s consistently disruptive behavior. (Picture book. 3-5)

Pub Date: July 22nd, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-4814-2046-4
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Little Simon/Simon & Schuster
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 1st, 2014




MORE BY ALISON REYNOLDS

ChildrenWHY I LOVE MY DAD by Alison Reynolds
by Alison Reynolds
ChildrenA YEAR WITH MARMALADE by Alison Reynolds
by Alison Reynolds

MORE BY HEATH MCKENZIE

ChildrenMY RULES FOR BEING A PRETTY PRINCESS by Heath McKenzie
by Heath McKenzie
ChildrenA YEAR WITH MARMALADE by Alison Reynolds
by Alison Reynolds
ChildrenTHE EMU THAT LAID THE GOLDEN EGG by Yvonne Morrison
by Yvonne Morrison

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenNO T. REX IN THE LIBRARY by Toni Buzzeo
by Toni Buzzeo
AdultDAVID GOES TO SCHOOL by David Shannon
by David Shannon
ChildrenBEING FRIENDS by Karen Beaumont
by Karen Beaumont