PAKISTAN by Anatol Lieven


A Hard Country
Email this review


Comprehensive examination of the resilient workings of an important nation very much in the news.

Despite a deeply splintered and inequitable society, entrenched feudalism, frequent natural and ecological disasters and incorrigible corruption, Pakistan promises to endure and become a significant player in the region, writes Lieven (War Studies/King’s Coll., London; America Right or Wrong: An Anatomy of American Nationalism, 2004, etc.). America’s lack of interest in Pakistan since the withdrawal of the Soviets from Afghanistan in 1989 proved to be a terrible mistake, as the United States now needs aid in fighting the Afghan Taliban, which the Pakistanis feel sympathetic to as a force trying to expel a foreign invader. Moreover, the U.S.-Israel alliance, the U.S. “tilt to India,” economic sanctions in the 1990s, support of a series of autocratic generals and today’s President Zardari, and the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan have all exacerbated resentment against the West. (Lieven notes that a surprising number of Pakistanis he spoke to believe that “9/11 was not in fact carried out by Al Qaeda but was a plot by the Bush administration, Israel, or both.”) Originally, the author titled his book “How Pakistan Works,” alluding to its dysfunctional working model that befuddles the West but manages to be fairly typical of the region, even next to democratic India. Indeed, with two-thirds of the population of the combined Arab world, a land acutely affected by climate change and one of the most powerful armies in Asia, Pakistan would surely bring down neighbor India, too, if it should fall. Lieven breaks down his study by specific region; considers the structures of justice, religion, the military and politics in turn; and, finally, in a skillful, insightful synthesis, addresses the history of and issues concerning the Taliban, both Pakistani and Afghani.

A well-reasoned, welcome resource for Western "experts" and lay readers alike.

Pub Date: April 12th, 2011
ISBN: 978-1-61039-021-7
Page count: 560pp
Publisher: PublicAffairs
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2011


NonfictionTHE UNRAVELING by John R. Schmidt
by John R. Schmidt
NonfictionTINDERBOX by M.J. Akbar
by M.J. Akbar
NonfictionTHE LONG WAY BACK by Chris Alexander
by Chris Alexander