IF ANIMALS WENT TO SCHOOL by Ann Whitford Paul

IF ANIMALS WENT TO SCHOOL

From the "If Animals" series
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Paul and Walker continue their If Animals series with this look at animals attending school.

Just what would an all-animal school look like? How would students and teachers behave? Previous series outings each had their strengths and weaknesses, and this one, unfortunately, seems to combine all of the latter. While the array of fauna is a plus, the students are just labeled with the adult name—Beaver, Lemming, etc.—missing the opportunity to teach kids the names for animal young that made If Animals Kissed Good Night (2008) stand out. Worse, though, is the fact that many of the animals don’t stand out as exemplifying their behaviors, instead merely highlighting what happens at school: Elephant stacks cardboard blocks in a tower, Mouse plays with shapes, Bear “hog[s] the triangles,” and Beaver is the reluctant student whose parent drags him to school. “Fox would rush to the story nook, / and bark-bark, ‘Goat! Stop eating that book.’ ” Well, at least Goat is doing what goats often do, even if Fox is acting a lot more like a herd dog than a predator. Onomatopoeia is emphasized throughout, and young listeners will likely enjoy chiming in on the sound effects, though the rhythm and rhyme are inconsistent. Walker’s illustrations are softly colored and delightfully adorable.

Lacking the perfect pairings of animal and behavior, this one just doesn’t stand out. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: May 14th, 2019
ISBN: 978-0-374-30902-2
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Farrar, Straus and Giroux
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 2019




MORE BY ANN WHITFORD PAUL

ChildrenIF ANIMALS CELEBRATED CHRISTMAS by Ann Whitford Paul
by Ann Whitford Paul
ChildrenIF ANIMALS SAID I LOVE YOU by Ann Whitford Paul
by Ann Whitford Paul
ChildrenWORD BUILDER by Ann Whitford Paul
by Ann Whitford Paul

MORE BY DAVID WALKER

ChildrenPEEP AND DUCKY IT'S SNOWING! by David Martin
by David Martin
ChildrenIF ANIMALS CELEBRATED CHRISTMAS by Ann Whitford Paul
by Ann Whitford Paul
ChildrenBEARS AND BLOSSOMS by Shirley Parenteau
by Shirley Parenteau
ChildrenIF ANIMALS SAID I LOVE YOU by Ann Whitford Paul
by Ann Whitford Paul

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenIF ALL THE ANIMALS CAME INSIDE by Eric Pinder
by Eric Pinder
ChildrenRED SLED by Lita Judge
by Lita Judge
ChildrenWHERE'S THE BABOON? by Michaël  Escoffier
by Michaël Escoffier