ONE OF US MUST DIE by Anna Clarke

ONE OF US MUST DIE

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Clarke switches from period suspense (The Lady in Black, This Downhill Path) to Ruth Rendell territory--with a contemporary domestic psycho-tangle that begins well, introduces some agreeable people, but soon slogs along into a murky letdown. Dr. Dorothy Laver, London psychiatrist, is being tormented by handsome, fiendish husband Gerry--a demanding emotional invalid who's jealous of her success, blames her for the long-ago death of their daughter (a medicine overdose that was probably his fault), and periodically tries suicide. And things get even worse when Dorothy meets nice electrician/student Peter: Gerry tries to kill Peter, winding up in the hospital; so terrified Dorothy asks her frail father to move in, along with teenage Nina (a love-starved patient) as cook. But once Gerry returns home, mayhem mounts: he tries to drive Dorothy to suicide (she goes catatonic); then Dorothy's father tries (successfully, to drive Gerry to suicide. And Dorothy, finally free, becomes a new (unpleasant) person. . . as Peter and Nina pair off. Rather confusing and far from plausible--a wobbly tale made relatively painless by the engaging supporting cast and Clarke's basic narrative aplomb.

Pub Date: Dec. 5th, 1980
Publisher: Doubleday