After a hardscrabble upbringing, through marriage, happiness, and tragedy, an unconventional woman named Mae never ceases to reinvent herself or reach for self-determination.
The backdrop to Hogeland’s second novel is the first half of the 20th century, when women’s options were fewer and doctors asked female patients to supply their husband’s signature to get a diaphragm. Nevertheless, the central character makes choices shaped by the need to live by her own rules. Born illegitimate and stolen from her adoptive parents by her own birth mother, Ida, Mae must accept their peripatetic lifestyle until circumstances force her to take control in her midteens. Narrowly escaping destitution, she becomes a live-in nanny in New York and begins to indulge appetites for books and art. Next comes romance and a transition into marriage and motherhood, her new middle-class status confirmed by a move to the suburbs. She loves her husband, a doctor, and their children, but she’s also traumatized by the business of childbirth, and after producing three sons she refuses to risk further pregnancies. This refusal and an additional heartbreaking loss shape her ensuing years, but so does her own resolve, grounded in Ida’s enduring advice when Mae says she can’t do something: “Become a woman who can.” Mae’s difficult choices and unpredictable responses make for an appealing read, as does Hogeland’s cool, precise style, lit with evocative notes: “the sun darting out like a fist from behind the buildings”; “they had the freedom of stray dogs.” But it’s Mae’s evolution, her singular, steadfast comebacks when faced with a parade of changing circumstances, that give the book its compulsive quality. There are implausibilities, some plotlines are overextended, and why no mention of condoms? Nevertheless, the assuredness of both narrator and protagonist dominates.
A satisfying saga. Life keeps coming, and nevertheless she persists.