THE TRUE TALL TALE OF A GIANTESS by Anne Renaud

THE TRUE TALL TALE OF A GIANTESS

The Story of Anna Swan
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A small, illustrated biography of a giant woman.

Anna Swan was born in Nova Scotia in 1846, and an author’s note explains she likely had “a rare medical condition called pituitary gigantism” that caused her to grow to nearly 8 feet. The story is written in the first person, a dubious choice for biography, but the point of view infuses the narrative with a sense of intimacy. From her birth, Anna is a spectacle in her rural community, where her family is credited with accepting and protecting her. “All the more to love,” her parents are quoted as saying of her, though there’s no direct citation for this dialogue, nor for any other quotations in the book, which could exacerbate concerns about the book’s nonfiction credibility. The strong foundation Anna receives from them helps her confidently set out into the world with a man she calls Mr. Barnum, who includes her in his Gallery of Wonders with other people with unusual physiques. An unfortunate, insensitive simile likens two men with gigantism to “totem poles,” and a later introduction of Anna’s husband, Martin Van Buren Bates, calls him the “Kentucky Mountain Giant” but fails to mention he was a Confederate soldier. Despite these missteps, there’s much to admire in this tribute to Swan, not the least of which are detailed mixed-media illustrations; done with a delicate folk-art sensibility, they depict Anna and her world as an all-white one.

A spare telling of a big life. (Picture book/biography. 5-8)

Pub Date: Sept. 4th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-77138-376-9
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Kids Can
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2018




MORE BY ANNE RENAUD

ChildrenFANIA'S HEART by Anne Renaud
by Anne Renaud
ChildrenMR. CRUM'S POTATO PREDICAMENT by Anne Renaud
by Anne Renaud
ChildrenMISSUK’S SNOW GEESE by Anne Renaud
by Anne Renaud

MORE BY MARIE LAFRANCE

ChildrenA HEN FOR IZZY PIPPIK by Aubrey Davis
by Aubrey Davis
ChildrenTHE LITTLE BLUE DOGGY by Lionel Daunais
by Lionel Daunais
ChildrenTHE LITTLE BLUE DOGGY by Lionel Daunais
by Lionel Daunais

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE GIANT OF SEVILLE by Dan Andreasen
by Dan Andreasen
ChildrenTRUDI & PIA by Ursula Hegi
by Ursula Hegi
ChildrenSTAND STRAIGHT, ELLA KATE by Kate Klise
by Kate Klise