Kirkus Reviews QR Code
UNFIT by Ariana Harwicz

UNFIT

by Ariana Harwicz ; translated by Jessie Mendez Sayer

Pub Date: Oct. 7th, 2025
ISBN: 9780811238892
Publisher: New Directions

A woman loses custody of her sons and her senses.

Lisa Trejman's hard-won family has fractured. She is alone in France, far from her native Argentina, and without the costume of normalcy she once wore. Lisa eschews each societally approved step back to custody (how she lost it is only hinted at); she prowls outside her sons’ school, harangues her lawyer, and arrives at a supervised visit bearing a chocolate bar and a knife in her purse. Lisa’s motivation to reclaim her children is a mixture, of unknown proportions, of maternal love, power play, and vengeance. The father who now cares for them did not want children. Lisa is Jewish, and her husband’s family made antisemitic complaints about the fact that their grandchildren would have Jewish heritage. Now, she watches from afar as the in-laws who insinuated that Jewish people “never wash their private parts” tend to her sons. That is, until Lisa sets her in-laws' farm on fire, grabs her sleeping sons, and runs. From then on, she’s a fugitive, journeying across Europe with the confused boys unbuckled in the backseat. Lisa’s narration skids from past to present in a haze of run-on sentences, forcing the reader to parse plot from paranoia. As she alienates herself from traditional human connection, she mocks it: “I pushed him into the river for love. I did what I did in the name of love. I molested her because I loved her too much.” Underpinning her venomous musings is the thesis that there can be no love without violence—that love is a kind of violence. This is no thriller, as there is no question or fear about whether something terrible will occur, only the straight and dreadful flight toward it. So assured is the totality of destruction that the author need not name its cause.

A violent, delirious blur.