SUCCESS WITHOUT FULFILLMENT  by Au Yong Chee  Tuck

SUCCESS WITHOUT FULFILLMENT

What They Didn't Tell You About Ba Zi Astrology
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Tuck (co-author: Winds of Change, 2016, etc.) explains the nuances and intricacies of the ba zi system of Chinese astrology.

Book 1 of this two-part work offers examples of ba zi, in which five “elements” (water, fire, wood, earth, and metal) are said to affect one another, in conjunction with specific times, to influence people’s fortunes. After expository chapters that lay out details regarding, for example, the characteristics of animals associated with different months and the significance of dates, readers encounter intricate charts showing each part’s influence on the rest. However, readers will require some background experience with traditional Sinospheric divination and astrology in order for this section to be of practical, regular benefit. In Book 2, Tuck presents 10 chapters on the triumphs and failures of various real and fictional people—such as Rosa Parks, Jim Henson, Robert E. Lee, Jon Voight’s character in Midnight Cowboy, Salvador Dalí, and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle—case studies that aim to show ba zi’s clairvoyant power. Numerous times, however, the theoretical predictions seem to fail to line up with what actually happened to the subject; in one memorable instance, Dalí is remembered as a “leader” of surrealism, but his stars foretold “follower” attributes. Overall, the book is stylistically and grammatically sound. However, there are several instances where more editorial care would have ironed out some wrinkles, such as the use of the verb “to clash” with a direct object in a chapter titled “Hey! Don’t Clash My Success Away!”

This book’s mostly clear prose and straightforward charts will illustrate elemental, divinatory principles to initiates, but it falters in its second half.

Page count: 309pp
Publisher: Partridge Publishing
Program: Kirkus Indie
Review Posted Online:




SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE ANIMALS OF THE CHINESE ZODIAC by Susan Whitfield
by Susan Whitfield
NonfictionMOON PHASE ASTROLOGY by Raven Kaldera
by Raven Kaldera