Branfman presents a rebellious take on the alleged inevitability of machine domination.
The author immediately notes the standard dystopian paradigm that seems to rule the cultural landscape: the idea that artificial intelligence and machine learning will not only replace many humans at their places of employment but also supplant humanity’s domination of the world. The view he puts forward is grounded in evolutionary development; he notes that humans evolved to be skilled in certain areas and less skilled in others, which is why humans created tools, such as AI: “In other words,” he writes, “AI is beating us at things we’re supposed to be bad at.” However, he confidently asserts that AI is not a threat: “it won’t likely care about conquest, and it won’t likely erase our intellect.” He takes readers through familiar aspects of AI discourse, from the job market to art forgery, and bases many of his contentions on what he sees as AI’s inherent stupidity—that is, its inability to do many of the miraculous (and ominous) feats ascribed to it—and he takes pains to address every fear or worry about the rise of the technology with ample historical antecedents. People have always worried that some new invention would destroy the very fabric of society, he points out, and there’s always been fears that some kind of new automation would drive thousands of people out of jobs. In all those cases, he argues—with pleasingly extensive footnotes in every chapter—the world went on, and often improved.
Branfman strengthens his presentation with consistently irreverent humor, as when he caps off a brief overview of the human propensity for violence by poking fun at himself: “Oh hey, look at that! All of human conflict, summed up in a few paragraphs. Neat!” He’s teasingly aware of the strength of readers’ skepticism, and at every turn, he seeks to bring light to the gloom. He doesn’t always succeed; skeptics will note how often the book opposing points of view into strawmen, and also how often the extent the book’s subject seems underplayed; one would hardly guess from this text how ubiquitous AI is in 21st-century American culture: “Will AI-generated deepfakes completely upend our society?” the author asks, for instance, before immediately answering, “In a word: No”—without deeply considering how disruptive it would be if people could no longer distinguish fantasy from reality on their screens. When people predict that AI will take over the world, he writes, they’re assuming that it will behave as aggressively as humans do—an observation that seems to forget that it’s humans who create AI. The book does consider the possibility that he might be wrong, but such observations feel rather bland: “Perhaps, as eons pass, we'll become intellectual again,” he avers. “Or perhaps we'll remain mindless until our species eventually goes extinct.” Overall, Branfman writes with energy and easy readability. However, some readers may wonder if his book’s nothing-to-see-here approach gives the topic the seriousness it deserves.
A lively, optimistic counter to AI doomsaying, but one that may not convince all skeptics.