THE UNWANTED

A refugee family struggles to be safe, stay free, and reckon with its secrets.

Fishman’s first two novels, A Replacement Life (2014) and Don’t Let My Baby Do Rodeo (2016), were both comic tales about immigrants. His third, by contrast, is a determinedly somber affair. Set in an unnamed war-torn country, the novel centers on George, a professor and poet; Susanna, his wife; and Dina, their 8-year-old daughter. All three are considered “minority-sect,” prone to the abuses of the national leader’s dominant-sect. As a civil war intensifies and George seems to fall increasingly afoul of the authorities, the three plot an escape. At a refugee camp, awaiting an opportunity to come to the U.S., the family navigates a consular bureaucracy, poverty, and sexual abuse. George grows absent, while Susanna eats compulsively and finds work cleaning the consulate, desperate to be close in any way to those controlling her fate. Fishman’s tone in chronicling this experience is heartfelt and dour, deliberate almost to a fault—George has risked harm to himself and his family through a byzantine set of betrayals that confuse his family (and perhaps also the reader), the mood leavened only slightly with excerpts of his poetry. The story catches a spark in its final third, set 14 years later, as Dina attempts to assemble some of the puzzle pieces of her parents’ lives; the style shifts into a higher gear, acquiring the speed and lift of a spy thriller while clarifying unanswered questions. Frustratingly, the earlier sections lack that same energy; Fishman effectively captures the fear, malaise, and desperation that comes with others’ control of our movements, but it’s particularity a drag on the storytelling.

An informed, earnest, and at times labored tale of escape.