Small-town screw-up Jake Flynn is drawn into a world of crime by a childhood classmate he hasn’t seen in 30 years.
Jake, 39 “and already exhausted,” lives in (fictional) Bellewood, Connecticut, with his long-suffering but remarkably tolerant wife, Mattie, the family breadwinner, and their two kids. They’re looking to move out of their cramped rental house into a home of their own but those hopes are plummeting as Jake, a one-time novelist, messes up at his job at an online marketing company. His circumstances aren’t helped by the sudden appearance of the loquacious Eddie Seymour, who’s every bit the delinquent he was when he and Jake were kids and threw plastic bags filled with urine at passing cars. After discovering Eddie living in the barn behind Jake’s house (both owned by Eddie’s uncle), Jake becomes an instant object of manipulation, suckered into posing with sexual playmates of Eddie’s just as they bare their breasts for the camera. In spite of everything, the lonely Jake gradually warms to Eddie, allowing himself to become implicated in a scheme to steal a valuable stained-glass window from a mausoleum. Eddie desperately wants it to complete an art installation he’s creating for the town’s annual Big Flea event. Trevor Cosgrove, a troubled teen whose father is in prison, and Eddie’s fragile mother, Edwina, the self-appointed town historian, also get caught up in the scheme, which culminates in a devastating event on Main Street and a shocking revelation. Making the hapless Jake and especially the conniving Eddie sympathetic is an impressive feat. Flaherty achieves it by tapping into the basic humanity beneath the absurdity. “Like, is this the end of people?” Eddie asks in the calm before the storm. He’s not just talking about climate change.
The human comedy takes a wicked turn in Flaherty’s masterfully orchestrated novel.