SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH UNDER ATTACK

A cautionary report on the immediate and long-term effects of recent cuts to federal science agencies and funding.

Mooney argues cogently enough that President Trump’s administration’s habit of ordering sudden staff reductions in federal science agencies and abruptly cutting off grant funds to universities and research laboratories not only threatens this country’s preeminence in scientific and technological research, but also fosters a pervasive atmosphere of uncertainty that stifles innovation. She quotes plenty of unhappy scientists, whose words reflect widespread hits to morale and careers. At the same time, she presents examples of threatened reductions that were rejected or restored by court order or other means, making it unclear precisely how much monetary damage has been done. The author covers the targeting of diversity, equity, and inclusivity programs and mentions government accusations of antisemitism that were leveled against Columbia University and other institutions as a pretext for halting funding. She quotes a constitutional studies expert who expresses his disquiet that funding was cut without any proof that the allegations were valid. In the end, perhaps hampered by the freshness of a topic that at the time of publication is still unfolding, Mooney focuses heavily on the impact of this anxiety and unpredictability around funding rather than providing concrete data readers would find more useful. The stock photos are few and dispensable; the backmatter includes a selection of marginally relevant resources and official web sites.

Superficial treatment of a timely topic.