THE COREY EFFECT

In this second-chance romance, a woman revisits old traumas—and the one who got away.

Andrea Scott has it together—mostly. The 28-year-old New Yorker works in marketing; is close with her mother and her best friends, Emma and Charlie Loughlin; and has fabulous sex with a man named Harry Stengel. But Andi’s job is unfulfilling, and Harry happens to be her boss and also married. When Andi receives a phone call that her estranged father, Ryan, has died, she’s forced to face the past she left behind. During her junior year of high school, Andi moved in with her dad while her mother took a temporary position overseas, and the teen soon became a victim of Ryan’s alcoholism and resulting abusive behavior. Andi got through the tumultuous year thanks to loyal new pal Krystal Rivera and handsome football player Corey Johnson, whose friendship with Andi soon turned into a passionate romance. Andi and Corey were prepared to be together forever until a series of betrayals during their freshman year of college led to a heavy breakup, and they haven’t spoken since. When Andi returns to her dad’s suburban hometown of Fairford, she discovers that he’d been sober for many years prior to his death. He started a successful home design business with Corey, now a single dad who’s still carrying a torch for Andi. Can Andi reconcile her painful family history and make her way to a bright, new beginning? (Corey had “always been a balm for my soul.”) Or is the past too much to overcome? Alternating the chapters between Andi’s life-changing high school years and her current reality, Dembowski crafts a lovely, sympathetic hero, realistically flawed due in large part to the trauma she experienced as a young person. The plot is carefully woven, dropping breadcrumbs to a satisfying final reveal where no individual is at fault. Though everyone’s actions have consequences, a happily-ever-after may still be on the horizon. Andi and Corey are a believable couple whose teenage chemistry has the potential to translate into a strong adult relationship, but only if both are willing to work on it.

A poignant, hopeful look at how the past informs the present and future.