I YAM A DONKEY! by Cece Bell

I YAM A DONKEY!

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A stern yam corrects a grammatically challenged donkey.

Beginning a muddled and maddening who’s-on-first routine, with enough back and forth to make youngsters’ heads spin, a donkey proudly proclaims, “I yam a donkey!” However, a nearby yam disagrees. “The proper way to say that,” it admonishes, “is ‘I am a donkey.’ ” To which the donkey incredulously replies, “You is a donkey, too?” The poor, foolish donkey never quite figures out which form of “to be” to use, and the small, bespectacled yam grows increasingly frustrated. When a cluster of vegetables—green beans, a turnip, and a carrot—comes along (and introduces new pronouns), the donkey has a grand realization. Sadly, it’s not about grammar but about…lunch! The moral, as Bell explicitly states in the end, is: “If you is going to be eaten, good grammar don’t matter.” Parents, teachers, and librarians may cringe. Kids not yet literate enough to recognize the visual difference between “yam” and “I am” will likely be too confused to care. The homophonic nuance is not a familiar language problem (unless you are Popeye), so many readers will not get the chance to rise above and see any humor—in either correcting the donkey or being invested in the joke.

This attempt to bring levity to an already-difficult grammar task for children just tangles the situation further. (Picture book. 5-8)

Pub Date: June 2nd, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-544-08720-0
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Clarion
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 1st, 2015




MORE BY CECE BELL

ChildrenRABBIT & ROBOT AND RIBBIT by Cece Bell
by Cece Bell
ChildrenINSPECTOR FLYTRAP by Tom Angleberger
by Tom Angleberger
ChildrenCHUCK AND WOODCHUCK by Cece Bell
by Cece Bell
ChildrenEL DEAFO by Cece Bell
by Cece Bell

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenI SCREAM ICE SCREAM! by Amy Krouse Rosenthal
by Amy Krouse Rosenthal
ChildrenEATS, SHOOTS AND LEAVES by Lynne Truss
by Lynne Truss
ChildrenYOU ARE NOT A CAT! by Sharon G. Flake
by Sharon G. Flake