In this alternative rock history, it’s the Velvet Underground, not the Beatles, who took the music world by storm.
Gather round, rock fans, and enjoy, in the words of L. Conway Bangs, editor-in-chief of Velveteen magazine from 1978 to 2002, “this freshly updated third edition of our compendium, a project we at Velveteen believe to be the most nuanced, most probing, and most succinct history of the rock era ever produced.” This history finds the 1967 Beatles album Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band tanking (“What destroyed Sgt. Pepper was a failure of imagination”); that same year, the Velvet Underground dropped The Velvet Underground & Nico, which set the band on course to become the biggest rock act of all time. The Velvets were untouchable; the Rolling Stones, for example, “would never become the British Velvet Underground; by the time they limped into the studio for It’s Only Rock ’n Roll, they barely qualified as the British Aerosmith.” Fans of Klosterman (Fargo Rock City, 2001) already know of his bottomless knowledge of classic rock and its practitioners, and readers who share it are unlikely to find a funnier book. And not that there must be one, but is there a point to all the nonstop straight-faced silliness other than to spoof the imperiousness of the rock journalist? Of course, Bangs’ remark that “If you can’t find your personal favorites among these pages, it doesn’t mean we forgot. It just means they might not be as important as you like to pretend” is a poke at both the sneering condescension of the music snob and the dubious enthusiasms of the music-listening public. Astonishing here is the steadiness of Klosterman’s hand: Even rock nerds will find themselves googling to learn whether some reported bit of rock excess is the author’s invention or actually happened. (It probably actually happened.)
Ingenious. Hilarious. Exhausting.