BODY COUNT

Sundae Valentine was only 11 when she met Holly Jolly for the first time—the ghostly legend from Wildwood, New Jersey, offered her three wishes that came with a price.

For Sundae, Holly Jolly wasn’t just a monstrous story, but something that changed her entire childhood. Flash forward seven years, and she’s on top of the world: Just named prom queen, she and her cheerleader friends are en route to Wildwood along with the football team for a prom weekend celebration. But this trip brings back memories that pink-haired, blue-eyed, white-presenting Sundae is doing her best to mitigate with drugs, alcohol, and hook-ups (the girls have a Slut Cup competition—the winner is the cheerleader with “the highest body count on prom weekend”). Things start looking up when she meets Lia, whose band is playing a gig at the Wildwood motel where she’s staying, and there’s a spark of connection. But little does Sundae know that Holly Jolly has returned. Crowley’s propulsive and engaging horror story is witty and fun, with its blend of gore and light banter. The legend of Holly Jolly leaves a bit to be desired, unfortunately—it comes across as disjointed in comparison to how well-fleshed-out the rest of the story is. But Lia’s bandmates, Dallas and Edison, frequently allude to horror movie lore, which genre fans will enjoy.

A thoroughly original and campy gorefest with a touch of romance; a genre-blending treat.