BELOW THE SURFACE

After a personal tragedy, a righteous Southern lawman wades warily into a racially fraught murder investigation.

September 1955. Department of Justice attorney Carol Quinn visits Sheriff Hickory Blackburn (Beneath Still Waters, 2016, etc.), of Cherokee Crossing, Arkansas, to request his help on an important case. Last year, Hick turned down an opportunity to work with Carol for the Civil Rights Section of the Department of Justice, staying in Arkansas to raise his two children with Maggie, his wife. Everything changed with Maggie's death; the grief-stricken Hick has mostly been going through the motions ever since. But so heinous is this crime—the shooting of black clergyman Father Grant, who is Hick’s friend, and DOJ attorney Ernest Kelly, followed by the torching of Grant’s church—that Hick feels compelled to help. Kelly is dead, Grant wounded and severely burned. Nicodemus “Deem” Skaggs has confessed to the crime, but Carol is highly skeptical. Though a neighboring sheriff says that Skaggs was “born bad,” an interrogation reveals a more complex personality and possibly a larger conspiracy. Skaggs’ daughter, Lavenia, denies her father’s avowed motive, that he sought revenge on Grant for convincing her to convert to Catholicism. When Skaggs is found hanged in his cell under mysterious circumstances, Carol’s initial instincts seem validated, though proving she’s right becomes harder. After taking care of Kelly’s remains, she’s supposed to return to Washington, but she can’t leave her friend in the lurch. At length she and Hick find the key to the murder in a similar crime, decades old, revealed by a church elder.

Hick’s fourth case posits an all-too-believable scenario and nuanced, relatable characters.