Kirkus Reviews QR Code
CIRCUMCISION by David L. Gollaher

CIRCUMCISION

A History of the World's Most Controversial Surgery

by David L. Gollaher

Pub Date: Feb. 1st, 2000
ISBN: 0-465-04397-6
Publisher: Basic Books

Circumcision has never been so enjoyable.

Gollaher (Voice for the Mad: The Life of Dorothea Dix, 1995) offers a fascinating and comprehensive history of the most common surgical procedure in the US. In a lively, surprising, and often graphic exploration of the practice, Gollaher touches on topics ranging from Egyptian genital cutting for hygienic purposes to the modern trend of "foreskin restoration." Gollaher discusses Jewish, Muslim, and tribal rituals as well as medical procedures, and his discussion goes far beyond diagrams and definitions; it also considers neonatal pain, surgical mishaps, posthumous circumcision, and various cutting gadgets. He covers every reason for the procedure, rational or not: cleanliness, covenant, aesthetics, disease prevention, repression of libido. "Historians typically strive to make the strange familiar," notes Gollaher. "But I hope also to make the familiar strange." Nor is he neutral in the circumcision debate. Opponents to circumcision cite the Hippocratic oath's injunction to do no harm. Gollaher argues, however, that facing thousands of years of cultural acceptance and a group of patients who could not object, American science seized the shears, using circumcision as a magical cure-all to treat paralysis, infection, and mental disorders. Citing medical, anthropological, and psychological studies, Gollaher casts a critical eye on a preventive surgery that he says "lacks a persuasive medical basis." He goes so far as to compare circumcision to female genital mutilation and predict that it will eventually go the way of bloodletting. Still, his study is well-balanced and intriguing as it attempts to look scientifically at an ingrained American practice and the history behind it. If you have ever wondered what became of the foreskin of Christ, whether Freud was circumcised, or how much dermal tissue bio-engineers can generate from a single foreskin (about six football fields worth), he knows the answers.

Informative, highly readable, and completely painless. (b&w illus.)