THE SECRET OF THE STONE FROG by David Nytra

THE SECRET OF THE STONE FROG

illustrated by , by
Age Range: 8 - 11

KIRKUS REVIEW

Nytra doesn’t stray far from overt Carrollian influences in his graphically presented adventures of two temporarily lost children.

Waking beneath a tree and shrunk to thumb size, Leah and her easily distracted little brother Alan follow the directions of several stone frogs to get back home. Their path isn’t as direct as it might be, though. Along the way they anger a Bee Lady—depicted Red Queen–style with a large head and stubby, neckless body—exchange courtesies with a group of refined teddy bears (or maybe lions?) in elaborate 18th-century dress, ride atop giant rabbits, and take a subway ride in a train filled with stiffly silent sea life clad in Victorian-era garb. In an eerie climax, they race through cobblestone streets lined with buildings that abruptly warp into towering, glowering faces. Looking small and wearing traditional nightclothes in the white-bordered black-and-white panels, the two children make their way through oversized woods and urban scenes depicted in marvelous, finely drawn detail. The storytelling does not match the illustrations in mastery; Nytra ends his odyssey with an abrupt return to a spacious bedroom and then a handsome but anticlimactic pull back to view the children’s country estate at sunrise.

Not much here for plot, but fans of the art of Tenniel and his modern descendants (Maurice Sendak, Charles Vess) will find much to admire in this U.S. debut. (Graphic fantasy. 8-11)

Pub Date: Sept. 11th, 2012
ISBN: 978-1-935179-18-4
Page count: 80pp
Publisher: TOON/Candlewick
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2012




BEA 2012: BOOKS FOR MIDDLE GRADERS:

Children THE BAREFOOT BOOKS WORLD ATLAS by Nick Crane
by Nick Crane
Children NATIVE DEFENDERS OF THE ENVIRONMENT by Vincent Schilling
by Vincent Schilling
Children ROCK OF IVANORE by Laurisa White Reyes
by Laurisa White Reyes
Children PEACE, LOVE AND CUPCAKES by Sheryl Berk
by Sheryl Berk

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenBLUEBERRY GIRL by Neil Gaiman
by Neil Gaiman
ChildrenWONDERLAND by Tommy Kovac
by Tommy Kovac
ChildrenTHE CHILDREN OF HAT COTTAGE by Elsa Beskow
by Elsa Beskow