In this dark fantasy novel, a teenager inadvertently opens a doorway between realms, allowing good and evil mythical beings to cross into our world.
It’s 1986, and Matthew Dean is muddling through his first year of high school in Beaumont, Texas. He lives with his single mom, Lina, and he’s endearingly nerdy; he enjoys playing Atari games and Dungeons & Dragons with his friends. He has recurring dreams that involve mysterious figures standing in a circle. One morning, the dream moves beyond its typical ending. Matthew doesn’t know it yet, but he’s somehow opened a gateway to another realm—and it’s not far from his home. Assorted beings walk through the gate; the first one Matthew meets is a friendly hobgoblin named Puck, who claims to know the boy’s father. Matthew has never met his dad, and it turns out that his mom has quite a few secrets, starting with her own origins. Unsavory types from the other world, including a wood nymph with a grudge, are on the hunt for Matthew, and when they don’t immediately find him, they go after his mother and his friends instead. Returning home isn’t a safe option, so Matthew hopes that Puck, and other allies he meets, can guide him to the land of faeries; there, he hopes to find answers, although they may not be the ones he wants. Meanwhile, Beaumont Police Det. Jacob Fusilier investigates an ongoing case involving missing local children. He feels personally invested because his 8-year-old daughter is the same age as one of the kids who’s vanished. His sleuthing uncovers disturbing clues and bizarre sights that Jacob simply can’t explain.
Tolin’s debut novel moves at an unhurried but effective pace, gradually introducing various members of the cast. Many are so well developed that when, for example, seemingly minor players suddenly reappear later in the story, their scenes have a tremendous impact. Many characters from the otherworldly realm are based on figures from mythology or folklore, such as a vicious boggart and the headless Dullahan. Readers will also recognize gnomes and a wizard who plays a crucial role in the narrative. The Texas setting is also engaging, thanks to a plethora of entertaining 1980s references, including movie posters, popular cartoons such as ThunderCats, and “blocky” VHS tapes (which contain potential evidence for Jacob to review). The story has its share of ferocity; more than one person suffers an especially brutal interrogation, and one formidable baddie, who inspired the book’s title, is a stonehearted menace. Several scenes are outright unnerving, although lighthearted interactions between Matthew and Puck help to alleviate the tension. Although the author vividly details various locales, his character descriptions are best: One has “an extremely large nose and pointed ears that jutted out from his head like the arms of a weathervane. His cheeks were flushed red, and his cracked lips formed a broad smile filled with intermittent teeth.” There’s still plenty to explore by the end, and a sequel is in the works.
A grim but riveting tale of astonishing creatures and an unfathomable otherworld.