Kirkus Reviews QR Code
UGLY by Donna Jo Napoli Kirkus Star

UGLY

by Donna Jo Napoli & illustrated by Lita Judge

Pub Date: Jan. 1st, 2006
ISBN: 0-7868-3753-5
Publisher: Hyperion

Trust Napoli to work her usual alchemy and make a fabulous coming-of-age story from the bare outline of the reassuring ugly-duckling trope. Told in the first person from the time he’s inside the egg, hatched by a Pacific black duck in Tasmania, the hero—and he is definitely a hero—rouses to the sound of his mother’s voice. But she has to let him go, as the other ducks attack him and endanger Ugly’s duckling siblings. He quickly learns that his instincts aren’t quite duck-like, or goose-like, so he is constantly trying to fit into habits and habitats that aren’t quite right. He makes friends with a wallaby, two geese, a wombat and a possum. Some of them come to violent ends, but Ugly learns from them what he is and isn’t and how to cope. When Ugly finally discovers that he is a swan, and not at all ugly, readers will have learned a great deal about various Tasmanian wildlife. They will have giggled mightily at the silliness of baby ducks and how the actions of cats and people might look to a young male swan. Tucked into this wondrously spun tale so deftly that one might scarcely notice are beautiful lessons about finding oneself, about fitting in (or not), about the implacability of nature and weather and the importance of maternal advice. (Fiction. 7-10)