PROTEST, POLITICS, AND PROSPERITY: Black Americans and White Institutions by Dorothy K. & Others Newman

PROTEST, POLITICS, AND PROSPERITY: Black Americans and White Institutions

Email this review


The authors offer this assessment of social services and employment opportunities for blacks as an updated version of Myrdals epochal An American Dilemma (1944). Theirs is a much less ambitious work, however; unlike Myrdal, labor economist Newman and her collaborators in several fields ignore black institutions in favor of examining--and faulting--white ones. Bounded by the Fifties debates over equal opportunity, the authors never directly confront the ""culture of poverty"" argument and other more recent interpretations of the ghetto itself; conceptually, the work might just as easily have been published in 1961. By the same score, they do not always take note of trends only now becoming apparent; overstressing the limits to gains blacks have made in the Civil Service, the authors miss entirely the very advent--since Myrdal's time--of a federal bureaucracy largely immune from political pressures (white racism) and able to enforce certain civil rights goals even during the Nixon and Ford administrations. Other, historical sections take a rather militant tone, with blacks alone credited for what achievements have been made in civil rights since 1940. Nevertheless the work warrants consultation; it is a clear and on the whole judicious synthesis of the latest scholarship on advances--and retreats--in equality of opportunity. Extensive notes and statistical appendices well substantiate its critique of continuing white racism and white institutional inertia.

Pub Date: April 26th, 1978
Publisher: Pantheon