Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WOULD IT BE WEIRD? by Edgar Garcia Kirkus Star

WOULD IT BE WEIRD?

by Edgar Garcia ; illustrated by Mariano Epelbaum

Pub Date: March 26th, 2024
ISBN: 9781961166035
Publisher: Nextcore

A young girl takes her family along for a wild ride through her imagination as she dreams up increasingly weird—and hilarious—scenarios.

An unnamed little girl sits at the dinner table with her family. As her mother urges her to eat, the girl instead asks questions that always begin with the prompt, “Would it be weird….” For example, she wonders, “Would it be weird if my mouth was a piano? And then, every time I brushed my teeth, everyone would cheer and clap!” In response to these increasingly elaborate questions, the girl’s mother is always ready with a response: “Yes, that wouldbe weird…. Wewould be so proud of you! We would even find a dentist who fixes pianos.” After the little girl, who has medium brown skin and bright green eyes, exhausts her mother with her questions (that involve everything from sharks in an epic dance battle to Egyptian mummies in pursuit to alien makeovers), she gets ready for bed and realizes she has one more question…but this time, for her dad. Epelbaum’s illustrations include bold lines and bright colors, giving the book an almost comic book–style flair that’s endearingly absurd (like the family dog using its eye lasers to blast a giant anthropomorphic slice of pizza). Both the text and illustrations infuse the story with a joyous feeling. It’s ultimately an exuberant ode to childhood, creativity, and family, and a pleasure to read for kids and adults.

A fun, laugh-out-loud journey through a child’s imagination with wacky illustrations—a delight for all.