WE COULD BE RATS

Two small-town sisters have very different experiences of post–high school life.

Growing up in a conservative, remote small town named Drysdale, Margit and Sigrid could not have been more different and never called themselves friends. While Margit graduated from high school, Sigrid did not. Margit went on to college, majoring in literature, while Sigrid worked at Dollar Pal. Margit is straight and Sigrid is gay. Margit grew up trying to be perfect and control every outcome because of her parents’ vicious fights—both verbal and physical—whereas Sigrid lived in a dream world where her parents were swamp monsters that she had to hide from and she spent much of her time playing with toys in the basement or with her best friend, Greta. The sisters come together, though, when Sigrid tries to die by suicide. The book is divided into three sections: The first is made up of Sigrid’s 21 attempts at a suicide note; the second, labeled "The Truth," is told from Margit’s point of view after she finds Sigrid; the third is Sigrid’s journal after she wakes up from a coma. The book covers uncomfortable topics in depth and often in an overly breezy manner. Margit and Sigrid are both far from reliable narrators, and with the many iterations of Sigrid’s suicide note and the dueling point-of-view sections, there’s a lot of repetition and different versioning of events, so it’s hard to track plot developments, characterization, and motivations.

A dark story of unhappiness, mental health struggles, and growing up with volatile parents.