Caplan offers a non-fiction account of a notoriously divisive and impactful psychiatric medical malpractice case.
In 1979, a physician named Raphael “Ray” Osheroff, suffering from severe depression, checked into a reputable psychiatric institute called Chestnut Lodge in Maryland. Osheroff’s condition only worsened during his stay; while in the facility, he paced the floor obsessively, lost some 40 pounds, and “his fine motor skills had atrophied to the point where he could no longer use utensils, forcing him to ‘eat like an animal.’” Chestnut Lodge refused to use psychoactive drugs to treat patients, no matter how severe their conditions—it was a place where “drugs were viewed as the enemy because they dulled the mind and inhibited feelings necessary to access therapy.” It wasn’t until Osheroff transferred to a different facility, one that provided antidepressant medication, that he managed to recover. But his story does not end there: The book follows the subsequent malpractice case against Chestnut Lodge meant to determine whether the “refusal to prescribe medication to treat Dr. Osheroff’s depression violated the standard of care.” The author examines the repercussions of the trial, pointing out that prior to the Osheroff case “a first psychiatric consultation rarely ended with a prescription, today, only in rare instances, does it end without one (or more).” Caplan observes that this shift reflects how practitioners realized they could face legal consequences if they failed to offer what had proven to be “effective treatment.” The text’s details are copious (including those pertaining to aspects of Osheroff’s personal life, like his relationships with his children) and at times repetitive (Osheroff’s compulsive pacing is mentioned multiple times throughout the narrative). Still, the book offers a provocative and edifying account of a historic case that raises more than a few intriguing questions about the standards of psychiatric care.
A highly informative, richly detailed account of a hugely influential legal decision.