WINTER MEETING by Ethel Vance

WINTER MEETING

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Ethel Vance's name will carry this rather slight novel into higher sales brackets than it would have achieved otherwise. It is good reading -- but leaves no sense of satisfaction, merely an appreciation of good craftsmanship in handling a somewhat difficult theme. It is the story of ""L' affaire Grieve"" as Stacy, who made a business of the social gesture, termed it, as he pondered its inconsistencies and preened himself a bit on being responsible for initiating it. To be sure, when he invited Susan, he asked her as a partner for himself, observer at the aics of youth in the form of a returned hero, ""Slick"" Novak, and his lovely secretary, Peggy . But Fate took a hand, and it was Susan that Novak chose -- and from one unpredictable night, ""L'affaire"" led to the seclusion of the Grieve homestead near New London --and to heartbreak for Susan, who cloaked it well, on her return, with gay new feathers. So far -- nothing off the beam. The unusual aspects of the matter lay in Novak's reason for withdrawal -- a reason Susan accepted at the end with a renunciatory gesture, for she had little understanding and no sympathy for Novak's confession of a calling which she thought a second death -- the life of a priest of a church she instinctively shunned.... The market for the book must be keyed to some extent on two obstacles -- ultraconservatives may object to the moral aspects (cautiously handled though they are) -- while some Catholics may resent the evident intolerance, and the insinuations against a man destined for the priesthood.

Pub Date: Feb. 20th, 1945
Publisher: Little, Brown