Kirkus Reviews QR Code
ELSE-MOORED by FORTHRIGHT

ELSE-MOORED

Immortal Holmes, No.2

by FORTHRIGHT

Pub Date: Aug. 25th, 2026
ISBN: 9781631231063

A badge cursed to speak only lies joins an immortal Sherlock Holmes in the hunt for a vanished prince in Forthright’s fantasy sequel.

In Newcomb, a walled city whose ancient protections rest on Olde magic, Varti is a “folk-spelled” badge (or constable); an Olde curse makes him lie every time he speaks. When Sherlock Holmes enlists him for an investigation, the case turns out to come from Queen Aelia herself. Her 9-year-old son, Prince Elzabart, has vanished along with Rival, the dog guarding him, while badges were occupied with catching a killer; the prince’s bodyguard, Willa Cyrine, was one of that murderer’s victims. Varti and Holmes work a tangled case, and Enzo Basker, a mage from “the States” who’s only recently put down roots in Newcomb, works his own angle: He uses magical “circle-craft” to bring back Willa from the dead. His familiars include the shadow imp Skrik and the water sprite Purdle who rides a newt. Enzo’s friend Arty, an inventor, builds a device that allows Willa to speak. Varti’s friends include a centaur intern, Wim; Varti’s dog, Doggerel; and the motherly harpy Ramage, who runs local eatery The Speckled Hen. The case strains the bond between Varti and his best friend, Phil, who has a secret of his own. Enzo, meanwhile, finds that his skills have drawn the notice of invisible mage Marsk who offers to take him on as an apprentice. In this sequel, Forthright builds a warm, lived-in world of chalk-and-copper spellcraft. The comfort of that world, plus Varti’s odd speech and his friendships with Phil, Wim, and Ramage, make the book more compelling than the mystery alone does. Enzo’s thread starts a beat behind Varti’s and resolves in the last chapter, giving the story two main characters and a late shift in focus. At more than 500 pages in length with a glossary, the size of the cast sprawls, and newcomers will lean on the glossary for the first book’s events. Overall, though, readers of cozy, gently steampunk detective fiction will find a generous, character-driven tale.

A comfort read with a magical hum.