Kirkus Reviews QR Code
BROKEN by Fred Berri

BROKEN

by Fred Berri


Berri’s historical crime novel combines noir, religious inquiry, and psychological profiling.

When 14-year-old Rosie Salvo is found murdered in 1949, former detective turned private eye Lester Caine and his assistant, Gloria Saville, join the investigation in Lantana, Florida. Invited to the case by police Lt. Ron Walker, they’re soon drawn into a mystery that includes nuns and priests, the secret lives of teenagers, and their own complicated relationships. Beginning with a narrow focus on Rosie’s death, the novel continuously widens its view, allowing Berri to provide insight into the Italian immigrant experience, postwar Florida, religious trauma, divorce, and art crime. As he tells the story of Rosie’s parents and their experience as immigrants in an arranged marriage, Berri eventually uses Rosie’s isolated murder to speak about larger cultural forces. While focused on Rosie’s case, Lester is drawn into conflict when his second ex-wife, Zimone Martine, arrives. She’s divorcing her third husband and is looking to recover valuable paintings her father purchased and her husband had sold. While this plot thread pulls Lester into the orbit of organized crime, it also serves as a way to humanize him and show his empathy. Eventually, Lester becomes an unwilling participant in a love triangle between Zimone and Gloria. The novel’s rich historical realism and distinctive protagonist are supported by the author’s detailed research. The novel integrates conversations on forensic science, Catholic theology, and Florida history into the narrative, which often helps the book avoid essayistic approaches and helps keep the story grounded. On occasion, this material diverts into extended speeches and threatens to derail the narrative. The novel is also burdened by sudden tone shifts from dark murder investigations to highly flirtatious or sexual interactions. Psychologically, the book explores Lester’s moral reasoning in contrast to Father Antonio’s faith and the killer’s motivations. This approach propels the characters forward in the story while revealing much about what makes them human.

A captivating mystery novel that treats its central tragedies with seriousness.