IN THE LAND OF GIANTS by Gabi Martínez

IN THE LAND OF GIANTS

Hunting Monsters in the Hindu Kush
by ; translated by
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A story about a yeti-seeking adventurer in the Hindu Kush becomes much more.

In his first book to be translated into English, Martínez, a renowned Spanish journalist and author, brings readers the mysterious tale of adventurer Jordi Magraner (1967-2002). Spanish by blood but raised in France, Magraner had been in love with the wilderness since childhood, and he became particularly entranced by humanoid creatures. This led him to the Hindu Kush in the borderlands of Afghanistan and Pakistan to hunt for the legendary “barmanu," the local term for the yeti. Magraner became enamored with the Kalash culture, a dying society of just a few thousand mostly impoverished people. Eventually, he ran into trouble, particularly after 9/11. The story of Magraner’s life—and his murder—is unquestionably intriguing, but the author’s choices in style and organization leave something to be desired. Intermittent, pagelong chapters focus on the history of hunting “monsters,” but these feel random and unrelated. There’s also a strange focus on Magraner’s sexuality, including an entire chapter devoted to speculations by various people in his circle. Furthermore, most of the photos included in the text lack captions or descriptions; readers may glean the subjects from context, but it’s a frustrating omission. However, in terms of pure storytelling, the author does an impressive job of turning Magraner into one of the “giants” of the title. As his subject’s behavior becomes increasingly enigmatic, the narrative becomes far less about yeti hunting than about not only solving his murder, but also understanding his charismatic and manic personality. As one friend noted, “Jordi was manifold—nobody truly knew him.” Martínez sets out to do just that, and he is clearly passionate about his subject, dangerously traveling in Magraner’s footsteps—but never arriving at the truth.

In this self-described “non-fiction novel,” Martínez weaves an interesting tale, but he takes too many creative risks to satisfy all but the most fervent fans of Middle Eastern and/or Asian culture.

Pub Date: July 10th, 2018
ISBN: 978-1-947534-10-0
Page count: 400pp
Publisher: Scribe
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1st, 2018




MORE BY DANIEL HAHN

FictionMOURNING by Eduardo Halfon
by Eduardo Halfon
FictionA GENERAL THEORY OF OBLIVION by José Eduardo  Agualusa
by José Eduardo Agualusa
FictionNOWHERE PEOPLE by Paulo Scott
by Paulo Scott

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionPASSAGE TO PESHAWAR by Richard Reeves
by Richard Reeves
NonfictionNEANDERTHAL MAN by Svante Pääbo
by Svante Pääbo
NonfictionTHE AFGHAN AMULET by Sheila Paine
by Sheila Paine