WINTER'S CRIMES 11 by George--Ed. Hardinge

WINTER'S CRIMES 11

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

It's by now clearly no coincidence that this annual British anthology improves whenever Hardinge takes over as editor from Hilary Watson. This new ten-some hardly approaches the glories of Crimes 9, but it's several cuts above Watson's 8 and 10. The stand-outs here are stylish reworkings rather than groundbreakers: Simon Brett's petit-guignol study of creeping psychosis (a mild, retired workman with a growing fear of drafts. . . and a sweetly meddlesome social worker); Jonathan Gash's tale of a coin-collector's lethal lust for rarities--and the gruesome revenge of one of his victims; and Michael Levey's first-person narrative by a rookie copper on his first big case--a case with an old but beautifully-handled twist. Equally engaging but finally less satisfying: Julian Symons' glossy re-exploration of the perfect crime (""The Flaw"" is too familiar); Ivor Drummond's murder among pukka-sahib fishing cronies. And the remainder ranges from sturdily routine (Anthony Lejeune's London blackmail tale, another of Ellis Peters' medieval diversions, Anthony Price's ancient-Britain military strategies) to second-raters by Gwendoline Butler and Sarah Gainham. Far from stellar--but a perfectly respectable batch from the British-detection source.

Pub Date: Feb. 1st, 1979
Publisher: St. Martin's