Maya, the sharp-witted Latina narrator and self-proclaimed “best detective in all of Hillside, New Jersey,” returns with her Bubblegum Shoes Detective Agency in this second series entry.
Seventh grader Maya Mendoza, best friend Jordan Freedman, “pint-size brainiac” Ava Agarwal, and theatrical new kid Clementine Steffin-Paller are back for more noir-inspired mayhem. Marlowe Middle School’s annual sleepover quickly turns into a case for the quartet when classmate Hunter Holloway, whose YouTube videos of himself singing are growing in popularity, is blackmailed into dropping out of the Battle of the Bands. This tangled mystery in the tradition of The Big Sleep leans into confusion and madcap energy. The story is packed with absurd twists, including an underground pillow-fighting ring, candy-fueled chaos, overblown rivalries, and suspicious schemes. Moldavsky excels at balancing humor with momentum. The stakes feel appropriately scaled for middle-grade readers, yet the narrative never talks down to its audience. Maya’s confident, humorous voice grounds the story, while the diverse ensemble cast’s chemistry keeps the pages turning as hidden talents within the group come to light. Each character contributes meaningfully: Ava’s intellect, Clementine’s flair for drama, and Jordan’s steady loyalty balance Maya’s leadership skills. The rich supporting cast, including Maya’s crush, Seth Levin, and local kid gangster and wrestler Arnie “Papercut” Arancielo, adds texture to the lively school setting. Though the plot occasionally prioritizes spectacle over coherence, the fast pace and humor make it an engaging ride.
A spirited, twisty caper with plenty of personality.
(Mystery. 8-12)