A bubbly social media influencer and a grumpy chef team up to save a struggling but beloved local restaurant.
Wealthy influencer Poppy Winfield and chef Jack Hartman cross paths on what might be the worst day of both their lives. Poppy has been dumped by her famous athlete boyfriend. Jack is having trouble processing the death of his mentor, Sal, leading to an explosive outburst at a food critic. He’s fired from the Michelin-starred restaurant where he works, which is owned by Poppy’s father. With nothing left for him in New York, Jack decides to head to South Florida, where Sal left him a rundown restaurant called the Sailfish. Meanwhile, Poppy wants to show her hypercritical family that she can actually do something with her social media chops. Following Jack to Florida, Poppy offers to help bring the Sailfish back to its former glory. This is an opposites-attract, grumpy-meets-sunshine romance. Reilly wants to explore the ways Poppy’s strengths tap into Jack’s weaknesses, and vice versa. Poppy has little in the way of life skills, and while Jack can cook amazing food, he’s woefully underprepared when it comes to marketing and promotion. However, aside from the physical chemistry between the leads, there isn’t much to their relationship. There’s a fine line between grumpy and mean, and Reilly doesn’t always walk it successfully. At times, Poppy seems like a punching bag for Jack’s condescending remarks, while her own upbeat attitude can come across as hollow and disingenuous. In addition, the pacing is of the hurry-up-and-wait variety. The way Poppy and Jack communicate their problems provides a sense of high-stakes urgency; their careers are hinging on the Sailfish’s success, but their actions undermine it.
A contemporary romance where the tropes feel like set dressing.