THE HUMPTY DUMPTYS

Sherman’s debut novel explores how abuse takes its toll on children, even long after they become adults.

The five Anderson sisters—Eva, Hedy, Lily, Sophie and Patty—grew up with an abusive mother and alcoholic father in small, rural Hardinsburg, Kentucky. Despite their traumatic youth and its ensuing psychological effects, the sisters have remained “strangely loyal to one another, almost a single unit,” even into adulthood. As the book opens, the sisters convene to begin their biannual tradition of cleaning their mentally ill mother’s yard at the end of the autumn season. The task goes according to plan until Sophie goes inside her mother’s home to find her murdered on the couch, stabbed through the neck. The ensuing police investigation reveals that one of the sisters committed the crime, and soon both the family and the public must deal with the complex reality of what’s occurred. This harrowing look at child abuse graphically describes how the sisters’ mother physically and psychologically tormented them; for example, she left them alone in a playpen all day, withheld food, and even killed the family dog in front of them. The novel explores complex, relevant themes, including the nature of guilt (particularly in cases of revenge), the ways that adults cope with childhood trauma, and in Hedy’s story, the difficulties of being gay in a closed-minded community. Sherman also offers an inventive narrative structure, telling the story from the third-person perspectives of several main characters. Despite its strengths, however, the book is overlong, and often hampered by irrelevant information; for example, the first chapter includes a large amount of medical and advertising jargon that never becomes pertinent later.

A heartbreaking tale about a family ripped apart by mental illness and abuse, but one that might have been better condensed.