Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WHY TREES by Hannah Gold

WHY TREES

by Hannah Gold

Pub Date: Jan. 19th, 2027
ISBN: 9798217060887
Publisher: Hogarth

Eight short stories of New Yorkers who work, or at least think about working, in the arts.

Gold’s stories have clever premises, fine sentences, and interesting, sometimes endearing characters drawn from New York’s creative class, and it’s possible to read quite a bit of this book before beginning to think some essential glue that keeps a book in a reader’s hands is missing. It’s more like a talent show than a play, or even a series of one-acts, which is not to say it’s not entertaining; it’s just not very involving. In “Notes on the Boyfriend Chair,” a narrator who identifies herself as a “night blogger” reveals that she’s producing her dispatch seated atop her boyfriend, straddling his torso, leaning back against his knees, and since "Absent Editor" isn’t around to stop her, she decides to produce a numbered disquisition in the style of Susan Sontag’s “Notes on ‘Camp’” about the Boyfriend Chair itself. “The Boyfriend Chair, after all, is not only a boyfriend, just as he is not only a chair.” “Cersei Lannister sit­ting on the Iron Throne is not Boyfriend Chair, whereas Daenerys Targaryen sitting on the Iron Throne profoundly is.” It goes on in this vein for quite some time. Throughout the book, there are many sentences that are little marvels of comic writing in themselves. In “The Loud Parts,” set at a boutique literary agency where one of the agents has died at his desk, one of the survivors recites a list of all the things she doesn’t like to read. It includes both English and American detective novels, stories set in the suburbs and in the future, and “leather jacket stories”—“the kind of story that sounds like a man in a leather jacket is explaining the most mundane details of his day to a person he considers an idiot.” There’s a good chance this collection is exactly what she’s looking for.

A vivacious display of writing talent and comic pizazz; plot development, not so much.