THAT KIND OF GIRL

A woman struggles to balance her family, her medical career, and a reckless affair in Bici’s novel.

Dr. Opal Collins is hanging by a thread. She is a disorganized but compassionate physician who deeply bonds with her patients at Ocean Hospital. Her husband, Fox, a radiologist at a different hospital, wants her to move into a management position so she’ll have more time to spend with their family. Fox wants another child, but Opal secretly stays on birth control. When the president of Doctors Inc., Ronald Aberdeen, announces that their two hospitals are merging, Opal is presented with an opportunity: Aberdeen promises her a promotion, and the two begin an affair (“we both need to want this. There’s so much at stake.”) Unbeknownst to Opal, Aberdeen wants an in with her politician brother-in-law to leverage his return to conducting medical research in New York. As rumors swirl about the allegations in Aberdeen’s past that forced him to leave New York in the first place, and Opal’s personal life becomes increasingly untenable, Opal struggles to find a way to save her marriage and obtain a less compromised work situation. To do so, she needs to confront a dark secret from her own past. This is the compelling story of a messy, complicated woman who is portrayed very empathetically despite her reckless, self-destructive behavior. Threaded through the plot is a sharp critique of the ongoing corporatization of medical care; it’s the most tonally consistent aspect of a story that struggles to weave together dark comedy and more serious subject matter. Opal’s friendship with a motivational speaker who moonlights as a stripper feels tangential, and the narrative’s attempt to redeem Aberdeen at the end rings false after everything he’s done. It’s hard to discern what’s pulling him and Opal together aside from mutual self-interest—they don’t seem to have much of an emotional connection. The inclusion of sexual abuse in Opal’s past and the Covid-19 pandemic bring a lot of weight to a story that seems to strive for a lighter touch.

A passionate novel hampered by tonal inconsistencies.