Kirkus Reviews QR Code
CROSS EXAMINATION by James E. Carroll

CROSS EXAMINATION

by James E. Carroll

Pub Date: May 1st, 2025
ISBN: 9781665776301
Publisher: Archway Publishing

In Carroll’s courtroom thriller series entry, a lawyer defends a man against murder charges and uncovers a dark corporate conspiracy.

High-priced Connecticut attorney Jamie Carson lands a new client, sales executive Herbie Jones, who’s charged with the illegal possession of a firearm. Police found the gun in Jones’ car after he was involved in a drunken bar brawl. Carson is bewildered by the fact that a convicted felon—Jones was once convicted of cocaine possession—would place himself in such a comprising position. When the weapon found in Jones’ car is found to have been used to kill Karen Polito, Jones is indicted for murder. He claims that the gun isn’t his, and that he has no idea who Polito is, but there is, in fact, a connection between them: The victim once dated Duncan Williams, the research director for biotechnology company Atoll Investments, where Jones works. In this complex legal drama, Atoll turns out to be a shady outfit under investigation by the Internal Revenue Service for possibly offering investors illegal tax deductions. Carson and his legal partner, Stephanie Marx, investigate the possibility that someone else may have framed Jones and killed Polito. Carroll’s knowledge of all things legal is expert, and he brings to vivid life “why cross-examination was the judicial highway to the truth.” The plot is tangled but not overly labyrinthine; indeed, some readers will likely predict the conclusion early on. The prose is sometimes awkward, as when Judge “Black Jack” Hogan is described as a person who’s “never accused of being armed in a battle of wits.” The judge complains to himself about one of Carson’s legal strategies in a clichéd manner, as well: “Carson thinks he’s so smart, huh? I’ll show him a thing or two.” Still, this is an entertaining crime drama, mostly because the courtroom scenes are so impressively constructed. An enthusiast of the genre will enjoy the intensity of the cross-examinations and likely overlook the novel’s flaws.

A sharp portrait of the world of criminal defense, despite sometimes-lackluster execution.