Seven Othellos—some actors playing the role, some real men, one ship—viewed as exemplars of America’s troubled racial history.
Shapiro’s long, prizewinning engagement with Shakespeare has generally favored a historical approach, as in 1599 (2005) and The Year of Lear (2015). Shakespeare in a Divided America (2020), considered the Bard’s relevance to our current toxic politics; here, Shapiro links Othello to our primal national sin. A chapter titled “The Execution of Othello” chronicles the blatant railroading of a slave by that name accused of leading a plot to murder whites. “Insurrection on the Slave Ship Othello” recites a grim litany of the horrific conditions endured by captured Africans transported overseas. “Shootout on the Planation” describes a gun battle between a former Confederate colonel and his two former slaves (one named Othello) who had joined the Union army and returned to Virginia to see their family; the Union veterans were accused of attempted murder but, in the brief interregnum of Reconstruction, were acquitted on grounds of self-defense. Shapiro skillfully weaves contemporary references to the play Othello into these chapters, but a whiff of contrivance remains. He more clearly pinpoints the significance of Othello to American racism in its many forms in other chapters. It’s shocking and enlightening to read of staunchly antislavery Abigal Adams’ revulsion at seeing Othello touch Desdemona in London production. The notable Othellos of Ira Aldridge, Paul Robeson, and Denzel Washington each spotlight turning points in the interpretation of the play and the acceptance of Black actors in the role. The book is filled with cogent, sometimes bitterly ironic material, such as a disconsolate Confederate veteran keening “Othello’s occupation’s gone” or Founding Father Benjamin Franklin, who owned a slave named Othello, expressing concern when the boy died for his wife’s “fatigue of nursing him.” Nonetheless, Shapiro’s many interesting insights don’t quite add up to a coherent take on Othello’s significance in America.
Scattershot, but with enough good nuggets to appeal to history and Shakespeare buffs.