A group of friends bonded by a terrible secret reunite in Gunhus’ suspense novel.
By all accounts, 15-year-old Wyatt Bucks deserved to die. He was the bully of the town of Chambers, “a real piece of shit destined for prison or hell” who terrorized neighborhood kids Mitch Ansel, Dan Coates, and Kelly-Ann Baldwin by means of physical assault, killing their pets, and attempted rape. So, when his body turns up in the Sagasett River, everyone assumes it was an accident, and no one cares enough to investigate other possibilities. But Mitch, Dan, Kelly-Ann, and their friends Rick Wilson and Lauren Renner know the truth: As seventh-graders, they killed Wyatt. Twenty years later, Dan is obscenely rich, Lauren is a TV actress, Rick is a Marine with addiction issues, Kelly-Anne works in real estate and at a strip club, and Mitch is an English teacher. The weight of their terrible secret weighs on their lives and psyches. They haven’t spoken in years, but one day Dan arranges a reunion to address the potential ramifications of their actions. A meeting up north at Dan’s family cabin reveals how little they all trust each other—as someone prowls in the woods outside. Gunhus switches time frames between the present day and the lead-up to and aftermath of the murder, allowing each character some room to breathe and develop as the narrative maintains a steady pace. (Wyatt, however, is a standard-issue sociopath, preying on the younger kids for thrills, which makes his death hard to sympathize with.) Once all of the “Fab Five” arrive at the cabin, the tension sags a bit, but the ending serves them up a deserved fate. Gunhus’ strength lies in conveying the psychological anguish each character endures, manifesting in grotesque visions of Wyatt’s corpse that haunt them all: “The face was smashed in. Deep craters in the skull, hair glistening with blood. Skin gouged. One eye destroyed…the intact eye blinked.”
A brisk, gruesome tale of revenge and its consequences.