An assassin and a scholar both seek a lost magical dark Art as war threatens their respective homes.
Known for cozy mysteries like Dial A for Aunties (2021), Sutanto makes her epic fantasy debut with a book that’s considerably darker than the rest of her work. Dual storylines take place a world apart: In the northern continent, Mara is a softhearted assassin in training at the isolated mountain fortress Tchu-Morrokhai. Forbidden from forming relationships with fellow acolytes—though she does have an unrequited love for her brilliant, brutal best friend, Lia—Mara extracts magical Art from her surroundings, hoarding Artifices for battle. The southern city of Velingard is the center of science and higher thinking, only 20 years rebuilt following an uprising that supposedly ended the noble Revven bloodline. Alivya Bellevue, daughter of the scientist whose alloy adtheriu hastened the revolution, studies the occult history of demons and Art, only to get caught up in a Revven conspiracy. Looming over all is the adther-powered Divine Empress of Kazgarth, whose bloody conquering spree draws ever nearer. Some of Sutanto’s humor is out of place in this grimdark setting, while other sequences are incongruously violent. Tantalizing clues are briskly delivered, so any revelations land more like inevitable plot machinations. The two storylines’ eventual convergence will not surprise readers anticipating the connection between Mara and Livya, cemented by an initiation, a kidnapping, a prophecy, and another revolution. Sutanto’s worldbuilding is strongest in the fraught relationships between various pairs, from assassins’ contradictory loyalties to the symbiotic bond between Livya and Cerra, her Sectator (indentured lifetime companion). Both dynamics raise provocative questions about who is soft, who is subservient, who is secondary—sparks that will hopefully ignite in the duology’s conclusion.
Emotional battles are more compelling than world-ending stakes in this tonally uneven fantasy debut.