THE SECRET FILES OF FAIRDAY MORROW by Jessica Haight

THE SECRET FILES OF FAIRDAY MORROW

Age Range: 8 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Fifth-grader Fairday Morrow's new home lives up to its spooky reputation, but she and her companions in the Detective Mystery Squad find out why.

At Begonia House, strains of bagpipe music issue from behind a padlocked door, grains of sand in an hourglass have stopped falling, and a malevolent weeping willow looms in the backyard. A magic mirror shows an invisible door; a wardrobe hides secrets and a portal. Ruby Begonia vanished more than 50 years ago. Is there also a ghost? Fairday has a new, helpful friend in classmate Marcus, and her best friend Lizzy can visit on weekends to help solve the mystery. What more could readers want? Alas, this contrived story unfolds through convenient coincidence. Too often, the writing tells rather than shows. Word choices give preference to vocabulary building rather than precision. The writers’ didactic intentions are revealed through advice about dealing with bullies. Fairday often reads and references a “prized possession,” her copy of The Wizard of Oz. She describes the “ruby- and diamond-covered high-heeled sneakers” that feature prominently in the story as “just like Dorothy's ruby slippers.” She doesn’t seem to realize the “ruby slippers” of the movie are “silver shoes” in the book she’s supposedly heard and read countless times. But savvy readers will.

A less-than-promising setup for a mystery series that will, no doubt, feature the enchanted old house and the magic shoes in sequels to come. (Mystery. 8-12)

Pub Date: Dec. 1st, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-385-74471-3
Page count: 272pp
Publisher: Delacorte
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 15th, 2015




MORE BY ROMAN MURADOV

ChildrenTHE EXTINCTS by Veronica Cossanteli
by Veronica Cossanteli
ChildrenLANTERN SAM AND THE BLUE STREAK BANDITS by Michael D. Beil
by Michael D. Beil

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenTHE WRONG ONE by Carol Otis Hurst
by Carol Otis Hurst
ChildrenTHE GIRL BEHIND THE GLASS by Jane Kelley
by Jane Kelley