BROKEN

A child welfare activist tells the story of how she went from working with Child Protective Services to advocating for a complete overhaul.

Pryce began interning at CPS shortly after enrolling in a social work master’s degree program at Florida State. At first, she believed her job would simply entail “making sure that kids [were] safe.” When she transitioned into a full-time role as a CPS investigator, however, recurring nightmares hinted that her work was far more problematic than she’d realized. Trauma seemed a built-in part of every case she worked on—and not just because of the parent/child separations CPS often enforced. Families, most of whom were Black, found themselves subjected to processes and procedures that never took into account individual circumstances and sometimes did more harm than good. Determined to find ways to speak on behalf of struggling parents rather than being part of a system that punished them, Pryce went into academia. During that time, she was asked to give expert witness testimony in a CPS court case, where she observed how systemic racism worked against an (ultimately innocent) Black mother named Jatoia. An episode of public domestic violence had caused Jatoia and her husband, Lawrence, to be charged with felony child abuse. Jatoia was fully exonerated after Lawrence confessed to dropping their infant son while under the influence of drugs and alcohol. Yet CPS still legally terminated Jatoia’s parental rights. “A realization hit me with nauseating force: The system had more power than I ever knew,” writes the author, who began to work directly with community activists to support parents “reeling” from a white supremacist system bent on policing families rather than helping to rehabilitate them. As compelling as it is humane, Pryce’s book offers timely insight into a racist institution in desperate need of reform.

An illuminating, necessary sociological report.