Kirkus Reviews QR Code
DAPPLED THINGS by Joe Taylor

DAPPLED THINGS

by Joe Taylor

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2026
ISBN: 979-8988023487
Publisher: New Meridian Arts

In Taylor’s mystery novel, a monk in a northern Alabama monastery is tasked with writing the biography of a murdered member of his order.

On Christmas Eve 2003, during midnight Mass, monks Julius and Benedict are (disobediently) placing Julius’ concrete sculpture of the Black baby Jesus in a new outdoor crèche when Julius is shot in the head by an assassin lurking in the nearby woods. The police are called, but the killer cannot be found. As penance for his involvement in the tragedy, Benedict is ordered to write a “critical biography” of Julius, including images of his many renowned works. As the abbey is targeted by local racists—the “Dixie version of America”—who are outraged that one of the monastery’s brothers is Black (and possibly gay), the monastic community must deal with an increasingly violent spate of hate crimes. A life-size effigy of a Black man is found hanging on the monastery’s meditation trail with the message “Go back to Memphis, nigger fag”; a severed human hand is spiked on a rock; and a black cat is stabbed in the neck with a butcher knife in an underground passage, among other atrocities. (“As yet, we have no sign proclaiming, ‘It was upon this spot, 12:22 a.m. Christmas morn, where the famed sculptor Brother Julius was killed by a 30.06 sniper’s bullet.’ I hope that we never will have such a sign.”) Benedict’s research leads him to the discovery that Julius had a child, Danielle, who visited him infrequently over the years. Now an adult, she’s a talented artist like her late father, and after meeting with Benedict, she decides to help him with the biography project. Their meetings grow more intimate, and soon Benedict is questioning his future as a monk. As Benedict contemplates vengeance (“My sinister hand gripped the hammer, willing it to smash into all those same squalid redneck faces, leaving them as bloody and broken and dead as Julius”), retribution, acceptance, and forgiveness, he experiences an epiphany of sorts: “Can we grasping humans ever really extend beyond our own labyrinthine ways? Perhaps it isn’t so much God, the Hound of Heaven, pursuing us down those ways, as we ourselves pursuing ourselves. Or perhaps there is little difference between the two—God and ourselves.”

Fans of Thomas Merton’s writings, such as No Man Is an Island (1955) and The Seven Storey Mountain (1948), will find the novel’s philosophical tone particularly intriguing. Merton and his work are referenced several times throughout; Julius even shares a story in a letter to Benedict in which he remembers slugging Merton decades earlier. The author’s slightly twisted sense of humor, spotlighting Benedict’s quirkiness, gives this novel an additional layer. The monk pokes fun at a “triple-feast day” honoring saints Marcellus, Macarius the Elder, and Honoratus: “A Pope, a fig-stealer, and a hermit…Well, Macarius, the fig-stealer, was accused of rape by a ‘wicked woman’ who accused him of ‘deflouring’ her. Deflouring?…did this gentleman named Macarius steal her cornmeal to mix with his stolen figs? To bake Fig Newtons?” The result is a compelling character study and murder mystery that takes on sensitive issues with memorable verve.

Much more than a whodunit: a sharp commentary on the nature of sin and the moral fragility of humankind.