Kirkus Reviews QR Code
FREEMAN'S by John Freeman Kirkus Star

FREEMAN'S

Conclusions

edited by John Freeman

Pub Date: Oct. 10th, 2023
ISBN: 9780802161475
Publisher: Grove

The definitive issue of a venerated literary journal.

For the last decade, Freeman, an author as well as an executive editor at Knopf, has curated a uniquely well-realized literary journal to which he has lent his name, with issues loosely devoted to themes like family, home, power, and animals. The 10th and final issue is fittingly devoted to conclusions, and features writing from an all-star cast, including Sandra Cisneros, Dave Eggers, Omar El Akkad, Louise Erdrich, Honorée Fanonne Jeffers, Denis Johnson, Mieko Kawakami, Rebecca Makkai, Colum McCann, Tommy Orange, and many others, with a fine mix of emerging and established writers. At first glance, that “conclusions” theme seems like a less-than-clever dodge: Every story has a conclusion, and any that doesn’t can be said to resist the constraints of traditional narrative—so any story fits the theme. In the end, though—pardon the pun—the quality of the writing included is such that there’s no need to quibble over Freeman’s criteria one way or the other. In one of three poems by renowned Song Dynasty writer Li Qingzhao, gorgeously translated by Wendy Chen, Li describes “Late spring. Why still / such bitter homesickness? / Ill, I comb my hair, / my regret long as each strand.” In a short essay, Aleksandar Hemon describes how, at the end of a visit, his father would sit down and demand, “Conclusions!” This was a habit that at first annoyed Hemon, but then, “as per the usual process, it became an amusing story I would tell, which then naturally led to my doing the same thing, except ironically”—and then not so ironically. In “The Endlings,” Tania James describes a pair of Neanderthal sisters, “the product of a bizarre and illegal in-vitro experiment,” who escape from their enclosure, and the young mother, on vacation with her husband’s family, who becomes interested in their story. Every piece in this collection stands on its own and is as expertly faceted as a gem.

Filled with expertly crafted stories, essays, and poems, this volume is a triumph.