THE MEN WHO INVENTED BROADWAY: Damon Runyon, Walter Winchell and Their World by John Mosedale

THE MEN WHO INVENTED BROADWAY: Damon Runyon, Walter Winchell and Their World

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

The opening chapter here seems to suggest that this book is going to have some theme or thesis: ""Walter and Damon serve as metaphor, the very paradigm, of Broadway columnist and observer. . ."" And social history seems to be in the air when the next chapters sketch in the Pulitzer/Hearst newspaper era--which made news into gossip and reporters into heroes. But soon thereafter it becomes clear that Mosedale has little in mind but a nostalgic N.Y. stroll through the Runyon and Winchell scrapbooks, along with familiar front-page lore and digressions into the big scandals, trials, prizefights, and other big stories of the Twenties and Thirties. As such, this is a fairly readable meander, though some readers may he annoyed by Mosedale's chattery, clichÉ-based style, his cheerful unoriginality (quoted chunks from secondary sources abound), and--most of all--his good-old-days droning, complete with gratuitous (often ignorant) put-downs of modern psychology, music, etc. Ignore all that, and you can probably enjoy the anecdotes: young Walter Winchell's rise from second-rate vaudevillian to barely literate columnist for show-biz rags, for the revolting Graphic (""gargoyle journalism"") and the Mirror; his gimmicks, feuds, and philanderings; Runyon's conquest of alcohoism, his rottenness as husband and father; his rise to fame with sports reporting, to fortune with ""cockeyed morality tales"" bought up by Hollywood. Mosedale also spends a lot of time quoting and arguing with a 1940 New Yorker profile of Winchell, though he then bases his last-page conclusion--that gossip in US papers is ""almost solely due to Walter""--on that same profile. And he gives Winchell full credit for early anti-Nazi propagandizing while not underplaying WW's 1950s Red-bating, his petty vindictiveness and rampant egotism. The connection between the two writers? Well, they both captured the Broadway essence--""Gangsters and speakeasies and darling, doomed children and hard-boiled newspapermen. . .""--and, when Runyon was on the way down, Winchell befriended him, later founding the Damon Runyon Memorial Fund for Cancer Research. Nothing new or significant, then, but a painless enough pastiche.

Pub Date: Jan. 5th, 1980
Publisher: Marek-dist. by Putnam