Kirkus Reviews QR Code
CYBELE’S SECRET by Juliet Marillier

CYBELE’S SECRET

By Juliet Marillier

Age Range: 11 - 14

Pub Date: Sept. 9th, 2008
ISBN: 978-0-375-83365-6
Publisher: Knopf

Bewitching despite flaws, this companion to Wildwood Dancing (2007) picks up six years later. Younger sister Paula, who debated philosophy in the Other Kingdom while her sisters danced, now assists Father on a trade journey to Istanbul. They seek Cybele’s Gift, an ancient pagan artifact so threatening to the Muslim political powers that all inquiries must be covert. Personal guard Stoyan sleeps protectively across their doorway and escorts Paula to the lone library open to female scholars in this restrictive city. A shock at the artifact’s unveiling leads Paula, Stoyan and condescendingly flirtatious pirate Duarte on a journey underneath a mountain, fulfilling quest tasks set by the Other Kingdom. Such challenges supposedly give mortals “wiser hearts,” but these riddles and tests have tepid answers. The story takes too long to find momentum, and Marillier troublingly casts both feminism and Islam in a bad light, heavily exoticizing Istanbul. However, despite these weaknesses, genuine emotion and Paula’s alluring love story create a memorable page-turner. (Romanian glossary, not seen) (Fantasy. 11-14)