THE MEN'S CLUB by Leonard Michaels
Kirkus Star

THE MEN'S CLUB

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

The opening and the penultimate chapters of this short novel offer the kind of rawly fresh fiction--in lunatic attack, orchestration, implication--that electrifies. If the rest doesn't quite match these sections, one can be both disappointed and understanding in equal measure. The book's premise is one shared by a small existing sub-genre (for instance, the movie The Bachelor Party): the getting-together with the boys, constitutionally unrevealing creatures made transparent by lasting out a long evening with each other. The unnamed college-teacher narrator receives a phone call (""an attack on my life. I get confused"") from a Berkeley neighbor, an ex-pro-basketball-player named Cavanaugh: it's an invitation to a men's club being held a few nights hence at someone else's house. Uneasily, the narrator goes. At the house that night there are six other men--Cavanaugh and five strangers: real-estate executive Solly Berliner (wonderfully cockeyed and unpredictable, prime Jewish-comedian stuff), a doctor, a lawyer, a psychotherapist, and a young businessman (who's brought along the marijuana). They smoke, they drink Zinfandel, they rob the refrigerator of the elaborate spread of food--chicken, a whole salmon, salads--that the host's wife has prepared for her women's group the next night. You meanwhile have become aware--distinctly, like soda bubbles up your nose--of the ubiquity and drive of the reversal here: men acting out a desecration of a contemporary ritual of women. And when everyone begins to tell stories (women ""talk,"" men tell tales), the book really takes off. These deeply schlemeil-y life-and-love stories are mostly pointless--not testimonies of humiliation, as in a women's CR group, but of incomprehension, of the dumbness to fall in love with drunk or coolly superior women; and they invite no larger lessons or sympathy. But most of them are hilarious, just galumphing off into men's blunt detours and hopeless strategies. ("" 'So why should I phone? To tell her I hate her?' 'No. Of course not. You couldn't put it that way.' 'How should I put it?' 'Tell her you love her.' "") After all the food is gone, the dining table is overturned, and the host takes out a set of throwing knives he once won in a poker game: they all throw knives for a while at the kitchen door. Then, like a pack, they drunkenly howl for a spell. . . . At its best, the comic extremity here is magnificent, especially in the traded stories, with their wonderful openings: ""Usually, about this time. . . I'm in my back yard, in robe and slippers, beating my dog with a magazine."" The book only stalls and becomes too loony-tune, in fact, when the narrator observes and privately records what's going on: these reflections seem a bit mannered, glinting and shifting and suddenly blinking out. Read this, then, either as a relentless, subtly psychological send-up of women's-lib fiction (Marilyn French, say) or as prime example of atom-smasher social comedy; either way, it's the talented Michaels' best work yet.

Pub Date: April 27th, 1981
ISBN: 0374208190
Publisher: Farrar, Straus & Giroux